Discussions that may get heated. Adhere to guidelines.
Moderator: Moderators
ratticusmc wrote:it also has the highest taxes, the worst roads and the worst health system. as well as being generally dirty, grubby and, well, i'd prefer to live anywhere than here (mainly canada or australia)
but it is a state health service which we benefit from via our taxes and NI payments
iank wrote:Ratticusmc... are you being serious about this FMoTL stuff?
It's the most ridiculous thing i have ever heard.....
You are telling me you use an ancient scripture written in 1215 stating and binding the rights of free and fettered persons of the country in that time... and you are using this as an applicable text to live under over 790 yrs later...
It makes me wonder first and foremost if you would even consider doing so if it did not work so economically in your favour.....
I would like to ask you a few questions if i may....
I take it you refuse to pay taxes under this following.... so you do not contribute to the state pot in any way....
1. Do you accept healthcare if you are ill?
- Whether it be from a GP or a hospital, unless you have private medical cover: I and all others working bloddy hard to get by and paying so much away in tax and national insurance to contribute to such "public receivables" and i would like to know if you have the cheek to consume these services for which you have decided you shouldnt pay for...
2. Do you have children in Education?
- Again, unless you are putting them through private education, the same cheek would be assumed if you were to be educating your children (if applicable - of course) and others picking up the tab.
3. Do you accept refuse refusal?
- Another public receivable paid for from the state pot, constituted from income/council taxation. If you are not paying in, seems a bit selfish to accept the benefits of a service others are paying for...
4. You surely benefit from road maintanence / streetlighting?
- Here we go again... if you dont pay in, and yet there are streetlights on all the roads... who do you think paid for that?!?....
For example.. of course it doesnt cover road tax, and tv licenses..... cars and TVs DIDN'T EXIST!!!!
This country as a developed country has built an impressive infrastructure of electricity, lighting, sewerage, waterways, roads, rail networks, business and community housing..... All along with impressive safety measures such as a justice system with a comprehensive network of police staff (oh, we pay for them too) and a supreme defense base of Armed Services which keep our country (you included) safe from a lot of the nasties going on all over the world......
All of this had to be paid for since the Magna Carter was written, and hence measures had to be put into place to facilitate money to be received by the state... Afterall: No-one at all is going to willingly pay for a stretlight themselves when they know if they wait and someone else pays for it they receive the same benefit once it exists..... I.E: Public receivables can only be provided if they are paid for by the public.......
Simply opting out of these duties is ridiculous when you are so willing to receive the benefits. It is no different than if you went into a curry house this evening and ordered a great big meal, had a great time consuming it all and then refusing to pay on the grounds that it doesnt say you have to in the MAGNA CARTER!
It is an old and outdated script that has no application in today's modern world. It is obselete. And any compliance to your followings of this script by any person of municipal or judicial authority is proof of nothing less than the lack of authority they have to overule such absurdities at their lawful discretion.
There were many taxes in the times the Magna Carter were written on common lands, arable lands, lordship taxes as well as corrupt local taxes throughout the land.... I take it you will claim you would pay these if the lords requiring them were still allive to claim them....
The truth of the matter is that there was no central governing body when the Magna was written, as there was no way to disseminate any decision quickly and effectively accross the country - hence rendering a central governing body uselss.
Now we have so many ways of broadcasting any decisions made - we can have a central party manage the building of infrastructure and governance of the country and its funds..... So people now pay the local taxes (council tax) to this cetral government... and income tax has been around since time began.... only it is more fair now then in your times as it used to be the rich who paid the least and the poor who paid the most....
I really look forward to your response, and i hope i have got the wrong end of the stick and that you are joking about all this stuff...
If indeed you are not, i really would like to see how you justify the becomming of a great nation's internal development and its external safety if all people were to have followed your beliefs for the last 790 yrs... And taking that point as recognised - how you can then justify yourself to be anything other than a freeriding parasite on society.
GSXF - I do agree with many of the points you expressed, however a few things made me want to add comments....
You say policemen don't have the power to stop and search your person without a warrant or confirming you as a criminal suspect.... However: my best mate's wife is a copper in London and daily has to impose her right to "STOP & SEARCH". The law entails FAR too much paperwork afterwards (bout 10mins for every search!!) but is a right they possess and are made to do on a regular basis as a deterrent in areas knows as 'hotspots' of youth violent activity....